Topic: External USB Blu-Ray BD-Rom Reader, DVD-RW, CD-RW Review with Pictures

Hey guys.

Link where I bought it: http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vi … 0121191160

After Cashback it ended up costing about $114.00

Here are the specs and capabilities.
 
Dimensions of Case:
Length: 14 cm (5.5 inch)
Width: 13.5cm (5.2 inch)
Height: 1.8 cm (0.6 inch)
   
* Drive Specifications:
* Internal drive: Panasonic UJ-120
* 2X BD-ROM Reading
* 5X DVD-RAM Writing
* 8X DVD-R Writing
* 2X DVD-R DL Writing
* 4X DVD-RW Writing
* 8X DVD+R Writing
* 2.4X DVD+R DL Writing
* 4X DVD+RW Writing
* 8X CD-R Writing
* 8X CD-RW Writing
* 24xCD Reading Speed
* 8xDVD Reading Speed
* 1.6XBD Reading Speed

* Compatible with Windows 95/98/Me/NT/2000/XP/Vista 

http://www.diblasiphoto.com/photos/442218846_Q6jry-M.jpg
http://www.diblasiphoto.com/photos/442219567_KLAZa-M.jpg
http://www.diblasiphoto.com/photos/442219926_8TsQs-M.jpg


A few weeks ago I got this external USB Blu-Ray player. Included in the box was the drive, USB Cable, Power to USB cable, and driver software.

The software comes with Nero for DVD and CD burning. The Blu-Ray software it comes with does not work at all. I messed with it for a few days before I wanted to bash my head through a wall.  The only thing that would play them is PowerDVD 8. It was very simple for me to find. PowerDVD 7 would not work for me even though it was set up for Blu-Ray Playback. PowerDVD 8 is also set up to play HD Movies so if you already have one of those drives, you’re good.

The driver software took about 5 seconds to install. From that point the drive is plug and play.

On my desktop the drive works perfectly just on the single USB cable.

However, on my N10J it requires the Power to USB cable to be plugged in as well. The N10J does not seem to have sufficient power output to run it. I first tried using the Power to USB on the N10J while the computer was on, but since the drive takes more power on start up, it shuts your laptop down immediately. They build that into your computer so you don't fry anything. This only happened 20% of the time, but that was enough for me. If you want to run the drive on both USB’s from your Laptop, the best way is to plug them in with the computer off, then turn on. I just bought an adapter that plugs into the wall with a USB output. It’s the same kind Ipods/Iphones can charge on. I also tried it on a powered USB Hub and that worked out as well with no issues. Either way you do it, it’s very cheap.

Once I had all that situated, I did some testing. It burns DVD's and CD's just like any other drive does.  Since it is only 8X DVD R and 4x DVD RW it takes quite a bit longer that I am used to. A DVD took me about 30 minutes for 4 GB, and about 7 minutes for 700 mb on a CD.

http://www.diblasiphoto.com/photos/442209205_6erTi-M.jpg
http://www.diblasiphoto.com/photos/442209230_A6xM7-M.jpg

Since this is a portable drive, I do no expect to be using those functions very often. I will be primarily using it on vacation to play Blu Rays and DVD’s.

With the PowerDVD 8 the playback is perfect on the laptop and through the HDMI Cable. I ran it through my 47” 1080P Vizio LCD and it plays audio and video perfectly. There were no hiccups and it was instant.

Just my Audience while setting it all up.

http://www.diblasiphoto.com/photos/442220302_hB6nw-M.jpg

Plugged into the Vizio

http://www.diblasiphoto.com/photos/442220660_MLc3D-M.jpg
http://www.diblasiphoto.com/photos/442220975_sUokU-M.jpg
http://www.diblasiphoto.com/photos/442221326_FsbbV-M.jpg
http://www.diblasiphoto.com/photos/442221651_NTTpb-M.jpg
http://www.diblasiphoto.com/photos/442222038_vadWg-M.jpg

The drive is very small and discrete. It is perfect for travel in hotels and airplanes. It will definitely drain your battery sooner as you will need to run it with the graphics card on, along with it powering the drive motors.

All in all I am very happy with this drive. This drive is offered in some HP laptops OEM as well as a few others. There have been many instances where people claim this drive does not play Blu-Ray in their laptops when installed OEM. However, it is their playing software that is the problem. I would definitely suggest this drive if you guys want a very small portable Blu-Ray Player that also reads and writes DVD’s and CD’s. This is definitely not the cheapest method for Blu-Ray playback on your Asus N10J, however it is the most portable and relatively cost efficient.

Asus N10J: Atom @ 2.0GHZ / 2GB Ram / 64GB SSD / Win 7 Pro

Re: External USB Blu-Ray BD-Rom Reader, DVD-RW, CD-RW Review with Pictures

Great writeup - thanks for taking the time to detail it all out for the community.  I'd be curious to know the CPU usage you are getting in powerdvd outputting a bluray with the nvidia chip?

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: External USB Blu-Ray BD-Rom Reader, DVD-RW, CD-RW Review with Pictures

Hmm, Im guessing that powerDVD uses HW accel?

Can you tell the difference between DVDs and BluRays on your N10 screen?

**********
N10J @ 2.1 Ghz | 2GB RAM |  320GB Momentus 7200.3 |Vista | 9300m GS @ 580/520/1450 | sweet....
On my way back to the sandbox, so if I dont answer a PM (ever) thats why

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: External USB Blu-Ray BD-Rom Reader, DVD-RW, CD-RW Review with Pictures

Awesome, cool! I might just have to get a BR player for my 60" Sony SXRD TV.

Acer AS1410: Core 2 Solo SU3500 1.4GHz | 4GB RAM | 250GB 5400RPM | GMA 4500MHD | 11.6" 1366x768 | Win 7 HP 64-bit
Sager NP8662: Core 2 Duo P9700 2.8GHz | 4GB RAM | 500GB 7200RPM | GTX 260m | 15.4" 1680x1050 | Win 7 Ultimate 64-bit

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: External USB Blu-Ray BD-Rom Reader, DVD-RW, CD-RW Review with Pictures

Thanks,  I was hoping to use the AsusDVD that came with it.  If I decide to go Blueray (was/would be my only player), I will look for the software with it.

Still debating about the TV upgrade (don't really watch enough to justify it).

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: External USB Blu-Ray BD-Rom Reader, DVD-RW, CD-RW Review with Pictures

Hi there

Looks good..I`m using a Xbox 360 HD-DVD external unit.

For $40 perfect.

V D R

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: External USB Blu-Ray BD-Rom Reader, DVD-RW, CD-RW Review with Pictures

supercrip wrote:

So no problems? Are the rumors true that this drive will fry your motherboard?

Rumors from where?

I think this blu-ray reader is pretty dodgy, if it works for the OP then great, its just that AFAIK, two full 500ma usb ports don't cause the N10 to shutdown, so obviously the reader has a power problem. I would have tried to get a refund.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: External USB Blu-Ray BD-Rom Reader, DVD-RW, CD-RW Review with Pictures

Gotta love Bullmastiffs, mean looking but total pushovers, great dogs.

That drive looks slick, I'll have to check it out!

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: External USB Blu-Ray BD-Rom Reader, DVD-RW, CD-RW Review with Pictures

Powering external drives on a motherboard always seems fishy to me, they arent designed to provide power to devices.  I had an external HD on my old laptop and it managed to set the drive on fire and tyhe motherboard failed soon afterwords.  It might "seem fine" but I'm not comfortable with running them as such.  External power supplies please.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

10 (edited by bart5986 2009-04-18 06:48:50)

Re: External USB Blu-Ray BD-Rom Reader, DVD-RW, CD-RW Review with Pictures

Found a good deal

"Slim Portable USB 2.0 2X Blu-Ray + 8X DVD+/-RW + 8X CD-RW Combo External Optical Drive"
http://www.dealextreme.com/details.dx/sku.23572
$109.45 USD

Nith, running drives on external power is just like many other usb devices that use the usb to power itself. There's only a problem when the actual hardware is at fault.

Thumbs up Thumbs down